Italian Restaurants

Authentic Italian dining from handmade pasta bars to fine-dining trattorias. Princeton's Italian scene ranges from rustic countryside to modern sophistication.

Price Range: $$–$$$$ (5 restaurants)

Laurea

Rustic Italian fine dining at the Hyatt Regency Princeton. Handmade pastas, seasonal Italian specialties, and a celebrat...

$$$
Cuisine Modern Italian
Address 102 Carnegie Center Dr, Princeton, NJ 08540
Phone 609-734-4226
Website https://laureaprinceton.com/
italianwine-baroutdoor-diningfine-dining
Pros
  • Exceptional handmade pasta
  • Excellent wine list
  • Beautiful modern space
Cons
  • Premium pricing
  • Can be noisy when full
  • Hotel location
Reserve / Info

La Mezzaluna

Classic Italian dining in the heart of downtown Princeton on Witherspoon Street. Cozy atmosphere with expertly crafted p...

$$$
Cuisine Classic Italian
Address 25 Witherspoon St, Princeton, NJ 08542
Phone 609-688-8515
Website https://lamezzaluna.com/
italianwine-barromanticfine-dining
Pros
  • Authentic Italian flavors
  • Intimate atmosphere
  • Excellent service
Cons
  • Reservation-only on weekends
  • Limited parking
  • Premium pricing
Reserve / Info

Mediterra Restaurant

Mediterranean-Spanish-Italian fusion on Hulfish Street. Locally sourced ingredients paired with an exceptional wine prog...

$$$
Cuisine Mediterranean-Spanish-Italian
Address 29 Hulfish St, Princeton, NJ 08542
Phone N/A
Website https://www.opentable.com/mediterra-princeton
italianmediterraneanwine-barfine-diningfarm-to-table
Pros
  • Unique Mediterranean-Spanish fusion
  • Fresh local ingredients
  • Outstanding wine list
Cons
  • Rich dishes can be heavy
  • Busy weekends
  • Premium pricing
Reserve / Info

Metro North

Elegant Italian-American restaurant with reasonable prices. Seafood, grilled meats, and classic Italian entrees in a cas...

$$
Cuisine Italian-American
Address 352 Alexander Rd, Princeton, NJ 08540
Phone 609-454-3121
Website http://www.metronorthnj.com/
italianseafoodfamily-friendly
Pros
  • Great value for quality
  • Spacious dining room
  • Private dining available
Cons
  • Not downtown
  • Menu can be inconsistent
Reserve / Info

Pastiamo Pasta Bar and Café

Authentic Italian pasta bar and café with recipes from across Italy. Fresh and dry pasta, antipasti, focaccia sandwiches...

$$
Cuisine Regional Italian
Address 301 N Harrison St, Princeton, NJ 08540
Phone N/A
Website https://pastiamoprinceton.com
italiancasuallunchpasta
Pros
  • Authentic regional Italian
  • Fresh pasta made daily
  • Great lunch options
Cons
  • Shopping center location
  • Limited dinner seating
Reserve / Info